Religion Doesn’t Kill People; People Kill People
It’s hard to be a nonreligious mother writing a blog about kids and religion without acknowledging Christopher Hitchens’ widely publicized view — or implication, rather — that religion may be akin to child abuse.
So I’m acknowledging it. But that’s about all I’m going to do.
It’s not that I dispute any of the major points Hitchens puts across in of his 2007 bestseller, “God is Not Great.” And that includes Chapter 16 (“Is Religion Child Abuse?”), in which Hitchens recounts the horrors of genital mutilation, priest abuse and sexual repression of young boys, among other things. But to imply that raising children to be religious may be abusive — that there’s a deep harm in, for instance, baptizing kids or taking them to temple or teaching them to pray — well, as Bruno would say: “Ich don’t think so.”
Unfortunately, there probably will always be freakish cases, like this one, that add fuel to Hitchens’ fire. But, generally, in this country, we’re not talking about real injury or trauma to children. We’re talking about loving parents trying to do what they think is best for their kids.
I’m not the most reverent person. The title of my blog alone suggests that. I was raised on a healthy dose of sarcasm, so irreverence just comes sort of naturally to me. That said, and this is the part where Hitchens officially declines to write the foreword to my book, my irreverence about religion doesn’t mean I think there’s anything inherently wrong with religion.
The way I see it, religion is a tool like any other. This may be the ’80s kid in me talking, but I liken religion to the candlestick in the game of Clue. The candlestick brings light to the old mansion right up to the moment when it’s used to kill Col. Mustard in the library. So is religion good or bad? Both or neither? Do we try to ban the candlestick? Of course not. Because religions don’t kill people; people kill people. People protest the funerals of gay soldiers. People fly planes into buildings. People create wars. People abuse children.
I’m not saying that there aren’t some truly F’d up things written in nearly every “holy” book out there, or that people do bad things because they genuinely think it will get them into whatever version of heaven they’ve imagined for themselves; but the vast majority of the Bible, the Torah, and the Qur’an speak of peace and love and friendship and kindness. Religion, at its core, is meant to bring comfort and hope to people, and to give them a moral compass. This is what most parents want for their kids; and it’s why so many of them turn to religion to accomplish it.
What exactly is abusive about that?

I agree, religion doesn’t kill people. It does seriously suppress their inclination and/or ability to think rationally though. I’m in a contemplative mood on this as I’m desperately studying for an exam in Philosophy of Religion. (I know, weird subject for an agnostic. But it’s the last module in a Psychology degree that I started many moons ago and I kind of painted myself into a corner in terms of subject choices.)
My daughter is 9. While schools here in South Africa are theoretically secular, and they cannot discriminate against you based on your religion, in practice the good schools in our area are very, very Christian. So she gets a serious dose of Jesus at school every day and has decided that unlike mom and dad, she is a Christian and believes in God. We had a conversation in which I explained that this is fine as long as it was her own decision, and not just something she says because her school is Christian. She didn’t have a good answer to that one so then tried to tell me that Christianity is in her blood, as her grandmother (biological, she is adopted) is a Christian and her birth mother (deceased) was a Christian too. (At this point I had to bite my tongue as granny is a nasty piece of work and definitely not a poster child for religion.) I tried to steer back to the fact that religion is a choice that you make, that we respect other people’s choices and that you can believe what you like as long as it doesn’t harm you or other people.
What do I want for my daughter, religion wise? My husband is a rational atheist, no spiritualism of any sort for him thank you very much. I think there is something to be said for standing in awe at the amazing things in our world – both nature and culture. I think it’s ok to feel that there is mystery there, things we cannot and never will know. I think that if you want to call the mystery God, and talk to it, then that is not a problem either. Just as long as your god doesn’t talk back and tell you to go and kill people with beliefs different to your own.
Loving your blog, Wendy! Have you ever read any of Daniel Quinn’s work? (Ishmael, Story of B, etc.) I find his take on the origins of salvationist religions–and their continued (often unintended) harm to humans & the rest of the planet–thought-provoking.
Yes! I read both, but years ago. I need to reread Ishmael at least. Thanks, Kathy!
Hi Wendy;
I do find your blog interesting and it is nice to hear perspectives of other parents trying to raise free thinkers, but as a person with a graduate degree in theology who is now an atheist, I have to respectfully disagree with your assessment of religion ” Religion, at its core, is meant to bring comfort and hope to people, and to give them a moral compass.” The goal of religion is to perpetuate belief by whatever means necessary. You say that religion gives people comfort, but I would say that it does the opposite. It dictates its own morality, and then demands adherence, threatening believers with visions of rejection by god, hell fire and purgatory. Worse still is that the more you study religion the clearer you see that it is a farce. I can appreciate that if you were not raised in a religious home that religion can look all warm and fuzzy from the outside; but it is not. It is protectionist, manipulative and self serving. Christians baptize babies because doctrine teaches that we are all born in sin, something to do with eve and that pesky fruit. Im sorry but I have align myself with Hitch on this one.
Catherine
Thanks for writing, Catherine! Obviously, I see things a different way, but that doesn’t mean I don’t appreciate your point of view. Hope you come back.
I’m really enjoying your blog – I admit at first, I thought I’d simply be reading those typical rants against religion, so it’s incredibly refreshing to see that this isn’t that at all. I’ve always wished more parents would simply allow their children to choose and think for themselves and guide them to that ability, so it’s great to see there are parents like you doing just that.
I recently read a book called Fringelogy that I think you’d find as fascinating as I did – it really illuminates the problems of not keeping an open-mind and how it’s even affecting science. If you get a chance to read it, I’d love to hear your thoughts on it.
Looking forward to more!
Ah, good! So glad you’re finding a fresh perspective. And so excited to read Fringeology! Thanks so much for the recommendation!
Great post Wendy. You are such a great writer and able to put your thoughts down so well. Thank you:)